While I havent personally ordered from this company, Id wager that most of your cheaper outsourced sleeves come from manufacturers like these
Its a cruel lesson an introduction to how Arkham Horror often requires you to dance around problems, rather than confront them head on
Base Set - 1st Edition (Edition 1)
Matoya has a chance to be an Up the Beanstalk like card, where there is a deckbuilding ask, but it is not such a big ask because of how cards are designed these days
he has the effect where, if his attack is different (can be less or more) than his original attack, he can quick effect destroy one card on the field, then his attack is reset to normal
The Charizard Gold Star from EX Dragon Frontiers, assuming it's in raw yet gradable condition, is the most expensive of the bunch at just around $20,000